Turek dreams of 91% top tax rate and a 57% small business tax rate 

Democrat Senate candidate Josh Turek wants to raise your taxes. He is comfortable imposing income tax rates as high as 91 percent.

Turek looks to an era of dramatically high federal taxes as his inspiration.

He pointed to the 1950’s as a model for tax policy, describing the decade as one in which Americans were “fairly and justly” taxed. He also stated in an Iowa PBS debate that the era had “arguably the most progressive taxation system” in United States history.

What Turek leaves out is how high those top marginal tax rates were. The top federal individual income tax rate reached 91 percent during the 1950’s, while the corporate tax rate exceeded 50 percent.

His enthusiasm for high taxes extends beyond historic examples.

Turek called for raising the payroll tax on Iowans by eliminating the cap on earnings subject to the Social Security payroll tax. He said: “we take the cap off.”

This would hit Iowans with a combined federal-state tax rate of 57%. Small-to-midsized businesses and the self-employed will be especially hard hit.

Uncapping the payroll tax would kill 1.8 million American jobs, according to the Tax Foundation.

Under current law, payroll taxes are applied to the first $184,000 of earnings. Employees and employers each pay 6.2 percent for a total of 12.4 percent. Self-employed Americans will pay this combined 12.4 percent rate themselves. Turek’s elimination the cap would mean that additional earnings become subject to the payroll tax, into infinity.

The math is as follows:

37 percent top federal income tax rate
12.4 percent payroll tax applied to income above $184,500.
2.9 percent Medicare payroll tax
0.9 percent additional Medicare payroll tax
3.80 percent Iowa flat individual income tax rate

= 57 percent Turek top combined federal-state tax rate on Iowa households and businesses.

Small business groups have weighed in against the payroll tax hike.

In testimony to congress, the National Federation of Independent Business said:

“85% of small businesses are organized as pass-through entities for federal tax purposes and report their business earnings and expenses on their individual tax returns.”

“As a result, business income earned through pass-through entities such as S-Corps, sole proprietorships, and partnerships would be subject to these additional Social Security taxes.”

“At a time when small businesses continue to struggle with inflation, labor shortages, rising borrowing costs, and general economic uncertainty, Congress should not impose another significant tax increase on entrepreneurship and job creation.”

Iowa’s economy is built around small businesses, and eliminating the cap exposes business owners, employers, and family farms to these higher taxes. By the Small Business Administration’s report, Iowa has over 280,000 small businesses making up 99.3% of the total businesses in the state while employing over 630,000 Iowans.

Higher payroll costs mean smaller paychecks for workers, higher costs for employers and consumers, fewer opportunities for wage growth, or some combination of all three. Higher labor costs mean businesses will have less money to invest, expand, or hire.

Turek has made his tax hike warning clear: if it earns, grows, or hires, tax it.