Semi Trucks is licensed under CC0
Doug Burgum, Secretary of the Interior: “We would consider an export ban if we thought that actually might lower prices, but that’s not the case.” … “Every idea should be on the table that will actually lower the price of diesel… [but I am] not at all confident that that would actually lower the price [and it] could actually hurt Americans.”
Chris Wright, Secretary of Energy: “The blunt tool of banning diesel exports definitely doesn’t work…If you can’t export the diesel that comes out of our refineries, you run out of places to store it, and you have to reduce US refining, which would put upward pressure on gasoline prices and jet fuel prices.”
Senator Ted Cruz: “I think it would end up driving up costs. It would have massive harm to the refining industry. We refine more diesel than we consume, and it would end up forcing refiners to reduce production. So it would backfire badly.”
Steve Forbes, CEO, Forbes: “Disappointed to see @POTUS’s calls for a U.S. diesel export ban. Restricting exports could provide short-term relief in some markets, but analysts warn it could also reduce refinery incentives, disrupt fuel flows and further tighten global diesel supplies. The better debate is how to expand U.S. energy and refining capacity, remove permitting bottlenecks and increase supply. The Trump administration has emphasized and delivered energy abundance and permitting reform. A diesel export ban would represent a very different approach.”
Steve Moore, Co-Founder, Committee to Unleash Prosperity: “The GOP’s “fuelish” diesel export ban risks refinery cuts without fixing the global shortage. You can’t fence off a globally traded commodity by executive order. Want lower prices? Suspend gas taxes and costly fuel mandates. Don’t punish American exports!”
Grover Norquist, President, Americans for Tax Reform: Listen to @SecretaryBurgum: An export ban would hurt Americans. U.S. refiners make ~5.3M barrels a day. Americans use ~3.6M. If we ban exports, refiners won’t stockpile the surplus, they’ll just cut production. Lower supply means higher prices.
The Heritage Foundation: “Yesterday, we issued a statement opposing new proposals to ban or restrict U.S. diesel exports.” … “Proposals to ban or restrict U.S. diesel exports are counterproductive. Export bans would not lower energy costs, especially beyond the immediate term, and would instead raise prices, weaken energy security, discourage investment, and undermine America’s reliability as an energy supplier…”
E.J. Antoni, Fellow, Heritage Foundation: “Instead of another government restriction, the answer is more freedom to produce, refine, transport, and sell American energy.” … “An export ban would also weaken the incentives necessary to expand supply. Refiners invest to increase capacity when they can sell their products to willing buyers. Blocking foreign markets would chill that investment and introduce new political risk.”
Daniel Erspamer, CEO, Pelican Institute: “This is price-control logic wearing an ‘energy security’ costume, and we’ve seen this movie before. Whether it’s rent control, wage caps, or the credit card interest rate cap Washington flirted with earlier this year, government intervention in prices always produces the same result: less supply, not more, because you can’t repeal the law of supply and demand by executive order. Diesel would be no exception.” … “The honest fix for high diesel prices isn’t a ban, it’s more supply. That means permitting reform, pipeline capacity, and policies that let American refiners run flat-out instead of policies that force them to throttle back.”
Jason Isaac, Founder & CEO, American Energy Institute: “A ban on diesel exports won’t bring down pump prices,” … “It will disrupt supply chains and hurt American producers. Diesel is a global commodity, and restricting American exports won’t insulate us from global market dynamics.”
Tom Pyle, President, Institute for Energy Research: “An export ban will do nothing but disrupt markets and ultimately lead to even higher prices.” … “most U.S. diesel production, and roughly fifty-five percent of the country’s refining capacity, is concentrated along the Gulf Coast. Pipelines and other transport links from the Gulf to fuel-short regions such as the East and West coasts are limited and already running at or near full capacity. The bottled up diesel on the Gulf Coast will not move to other U.S. markets any faster, but it will depress local prices, likely prompting producers to cut runs. Those cutbacks would shrink overall fuel supply, lift global prices, and ultimately pump prices higher at home. Furthermore, these refineries have been running at a record-setting ninety-five percent utilization rate for over 14 weeks. If they can’t export diesel, the logical thing for them to do would be do shut down for maintenance, reducing supply even further.”
John R. Puri, National Review: “The first problem is that refiners do not have anywhere near the infrastructure to physically deliver almost 3o percent more diesel to consumers across the country instantaneously, so endpoint supply would expand only in the near vicinity of refineries. The Gulf Coast would very likely see depressed prices, but South Dakotans would be out of luck.” … “A second and far greater problem is that, insofar as an export ban does depress prices, it would do nothing to change the cost of crude oil that refiners must pay to produce the fuel. Diesel prices did not jump on their own; they were led by surging oil prices. A sudden fall in the former but no decrease in the latter would compress refiners’ margins on diesel production, and potentially render it unprofitable. Refiners would naturally respond by cutting production and shifting their capacity to other fuels. Supply would decline until diesel prices are realigned with input costs.” … “The result would be diesel prices returning to approximately current levels, but with much lower U.S. production and tens of billions of dollars in lost export revenue. Momentary, selective relief would give way to long-term impoverishment.”
American Action Forum: “President Trump is considering a diesel export ban after prices hit a record $6.53 per gallon. But export restrictions would trap Gulf Coast supplies, force refiners to cut output, and push fuel prices higher. #Eakinomics“
Ryan Young, Senior Economist, Competitive Enterprise Institute: “There are no short-term fixes for high diesel prices. Export bans would politicize energy markets and invite retaliation while failing to solve the fundamental problem of scarcity. But there are at least two long-term solutions. Domestically, reducing regulatory barriers such as permits can encourage more capacity to come online. Abroad, a credible end to the Iran conflict will help to restore lost capacity and make diesel prices less volatile.Both of these options will take months or years to implement. But they will pay off in the long run by making diesel more abundant and more resilient against supply shocks. In the meantime, policy choices have consequences, and we have no choice but to face them.”
Erick Erickson: “It would still be a mistake, and the people who would pay for it are the people it is supposed to help. (…) The United States is the largest source of diesel on the world market. Russia, the second largest, has already banned its exports because Ukrainian drones keep setting its refineries on fire. That is a major reason prices are where they are. If we pull our barrels too, the world loses its two biggest suppliers at once, and diesel in Rotterdam, Singapore, and Shanghai skyrockets. The shipping companies will not eat that cost. They will pass it along in freight rates, and freight rates end up in the price of everything that comes off the boat. (…) The ban would not even deliver the relief promised at home. Refiners do not make diesel in isolation. When they lose their export customers, they cut production, and that means less gasoline and jet fuel too. (…) It is a short-term election play that cuts off our nose to spite our face, and the costs would spread far beyond the pump to every aisle of the grocery store.“
Editors, National Review: “The policy has cheap appeal ahead of the midterms, but it would wreak havoc on energy markets at home and abroad. … To the extent that bottled-up diesel suppresses any domestic prices, it would incentivize refiners to slash their output. Without the infrastructure to transport massive amounts of additional diesel to domestic buyers, storage tanks would fill quickly. … To reduce costs sustainably, tight global fuel supplies must be restored and expanded — not hoarded.”