Paying Sen. Gallego's Robot Tax
If it moves, tax it.
This old adage from Ronald Reagan remains undefeated in the digital age. As the shiny new industry driving the creation of new wealth in America at the moment, it is unsurprising that politicians would seek to tax AI. In politician logic, grabbing the golden eggs while the goose is still laying them only makes sense.
For the rest of us, taxing the new technology that is driving virtually all economic growth and job creation in the United States right now might seem absurd. Seeking to tax the most vibrant, growing sectors is nothing new from Democrats – where it gets novel are the different ways they want to try.
Senator Ruben Gallego (D-Ariz.) has proposed a “robot tax” on every job eliminated by AI and a 10% tax on data centers to attack the infrastructure powering it. The IRS would get to assess a tax on any company laying off workers due to a bad quarter if they decide AI was somehow involved. Employers would also have to keep paying the payroll tax to contribute to workers’ Social Security. Meanwhile, the bill would increase the minimum wage and surge tax dollars into workforce training initiatives for displaced workers.
Not to be outdone, Gallego’s own colleague from Arizona, Senator Mark Kelly, has proposed the Make AI Work for Americans Act, which would impose its own 50% gross receipts tax on all AI companies’ profits, in addition to taxes on digital advertising and an excise tax on AI outputs, to subsidize workforce training.
The bill’s workforce training provisions are especially harmful because, as Nicholas Thielman and Justin Callais have pointed out, they would double-down on restrictive occupational licensing arrangements that reduce competition and raise costs for consumers. Arizona was the state that pioneered reforming this system to honor certifications in other states – Senator Kelly overturning this from Washington would be a step backwards for the Grand Canyon State.
However it is implemented, the Kelly bill also speaks to the underlying assumption of most Democrat proposals that widespread job displacement will necessarily follow the development of better AI, and workers will require massive wealth redistributions. Though AI job losses is a widespread fear, there is as yet no evidence that it is happening. Enacting massive wealth redistribution out of fear of something that has yet to happen is a terrible basis for public policy. Anything to get their hands on some of that AI largesse.
Senator Kelly’s Horizon Fund, the slush fund through which his subsidies would run, would have union bosses on its board and dispense its largesse to cover up to 75% of the lost wages of workers displaced by technology. This despite evidence that bigger unemployment checks prolong unemployment.
How exactly do they determine if someone’s job was lost to technology versus any other plausible explanation? The union bosses on the board would decide. The public should perhaps be worried about corruption.
The Senators from Arizona are not alone. Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) recently penned an op-ed in TIME magazine advocating a national AI tax. Meanwhile, Senator Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) has proposed a gross receipts tax for data centers, and Senator Bernie Moreno (D-Ohio) has endorsed a similar proposal. Bipartisan backlash to the new technology driving job creation is growing, and Democrats are especially eager to get what they can while the getting’s good.
Democrats are positioning themselves as the opponents of innovation. The only innovation they seem to like is coming up with creative ways to extract wealth from the productivity of the American people.